Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christopher Lind's avatar

Christian culture has offered little support to children as they grow up and have to navigate the complexity of extended family and their family or origin as they seek to live in obedience to Christ and establish their family.

I think it’s awesome that you’re ministering to that community.

You also did a phenomenal job of shining a light on what it can really look like to “provoke” or “discourage” your children.

There’s an inherent power dynamic in play that many don’t want to acknowledge. Parents have the upper hand in the relationship and as such need to recognize the diversity of how that dynamic can cause real harm.

Well done!

Is my Mike on's avatar

I offer a challenge. I've read much of your Substack and don't know your situation personally. But this post specifically made me feel something that I do have experience with.

Paul is trying to protect vulnerable dependents (children) from overbearing authorities. Engaging on social media isn’t a true conversation, nor is it a healthy place for family discourse. There is a clear power dynamic in Paul’s words that simply doesn’t apply to adults engaging on Facebook.

You’re an adult with kids of your own—a life your parents likely want to be involved with. You are actually the one with the upper hand now. You hold something they yearn for, and by your own admission, you are holding it back.

That cumulative effect you mentioned is now being enforced by you onto them. You are highly capable of crushing their thumos. They have likely thrown up their hands saying, 'What is the point of even trying?' In this modern dynamic, they are the ones experiencing the exasperation Paul was warning about.

I would also caution that by invoking God, the Bible, and a need for repentance, you are elevating your personal demands to divine mandates. You are equating your own personal conditions for a relationship with God’s conditions for a relationship. Whether intentional or not, this is a tactic often used to make others feel spiritually inadequate and guilty.

You are obviously feeling deep pain. Even digital doors being shut can feel like a profound rejection. However, please don't discount your own role in this. Your essay is filled with the language of reconciliation and boundaries, yet it ultimately demands compliance and control. You have played a role in their response, regardless of whether you agree with their methods.

If you truly want reconciliation: Set aside the clinical labels. Know the difference between boundaries and demands. Boundaries protect you; demands try to control others. A list of demands is not conducive to healing. Speak without theological debates. Speak practically about how you can begin to progress privately.

Wishing you healing and love.

16 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?